![Gardiners Island mysterious private island owned same family for 380 years in Hamptons Captain Kidd | Daily Mail Online Gardiners Island mysterious private island owned same family for 380 years in Hamptons Captain Kidd | Daily Mail Online](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2019/03/29/19/11331380-0-image-a-36_1553888407901.jpg)
Gardiners Island mysterious private island owned same family for 380 years in Hamptons Captain Kidd | Daily Mail Online
Montauk Parasail - Gardiners Island Originally known as the island of Manchonake, Gardiners Island was purchased in 1639 by Lion Gardiner from the Montaukett Indians for "a large black dog, some powder
![Gardiners Island mysterious private island owned same family for 380 years in Hamptons Captain Kidd | Daily Mail Online Gardiners Island mysterious private island owned same family for 380 years in Hamptons Captain Kidd | Daily Mail Online](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2019/04/02/15/11769944-0-image-a-6_1554217125154.jpg)
Gardiners Island mysterious private island owned same family for 380 years in Hamptons Captain Kidd | Daily Mail Online
![SUFFOLK CLOSEUP - Gardiner's Island LI's Ecological And Historical Jewel - Article Archive (Chronological) - Smithtown Matters - Online Local News about Smithtown, Kings Park, St James, Nesconset, Commack, Hauppauge, Ft. Salonga SUFFOLK CLOSEUP - Gardiner's Island LI's Ecological And Historical Jewel - Article Archive (Chronological) - Smithtown Matters - Online Local News about Smithtown, Kings Park, St James, Nesconset, Commack, Hauppauge, Ft. Salonga](https://www.smithtownmatters.com/storage/karlgrossman.jpg?__SQUARESPACE_CACHEVERSION=1541075646250)
SUFFOLK CLOSEUP - Gardiner's Island LI's Ecological And Historical Jewel - Article Archive (Chronological) - Smithtown Matters - Online Local News about Smithtown, Kings Park, St James, Nesconset, Commack, Hauppauge, Ft. Salonga
![Gardiners Island mysterious private island owned same family for 380 years in Hamptons Captain Kidd | Daily Mail Online Gardiners Island mysterious private island owned same family for 380 years in Hamptons Captain Kidd | Daily Mail Online](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2019/04/01/15/11633492-6866479-image-a-1_1554129660860.jpg)
Gardiners Island mysterious private island owned same family for 380 years in Hamptons Captain Kidd | Daily Mail Online
![Gardiners Island mysterious private island owned same family for 380 years in Hamptons Captain Kidd | Daily Mail Online Gardiners Island mysterious private island owned same family for 380 years in Hamptons Captain Kidd | Daily Mail Online](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2019/03/29/20/11331364-0-image-a-60_1553889939431.jpg)
Gardiners Island mysterious private island owned same family for 380 years in Hamptons Captain Kidd | Daily Mail Online
![Gardiners Island mysterious private island owned same family for 380 years in Hamptons Captain Kidd | Daily Mail Online Gardiners Island mysterious private island owned same family for 380 years in Hamptons Captain Kidd | Daily Mail Online](https://i.dailymail.co.uk/1s/2019/03/29/20/11543340-0-image-a-72_1553890251951.jpg)
Gardiners Island mysterious private island owned same family for 380 years in Hamptons Captain Kidd | Daily Mail Online
![Alexandra Creel Wed at St. James To Peter F. Tufo; Daughter of Justice is Married to Lawyer, a Beloit Alumnus - The New York Times Alexandra Creel Wed at St. James To Peter F. Tufo; Daughter of Justice is Married to Lawyer, a Beloit Alumnus - The New York Times](https://s1.nyt.com/timesmachine/pages/1/1964/12/10/99402693_360W.png?quality=75&auto=webp&disable=upscale)